Good idea for Harry Potter fanfiction?

Does anyone think that this is a good idea for an AU HP fanfic? (warning – contains a Harry sibling, so if that sort of thing wants to make you gauge your eyes out, proceed with caution!)

On Halloween when James and Lily were killed and Harry defeated Lord Voldemort, there was someone else in the house too. His twin sister. The reason why she survived is because basically, Voldemort couldn’t get round to killing her. He was going to finish her off after Harry, but since he was nearly dead, he didn’t have much of an opportunity.

Then when the twins are placed on the Dursley’s doorstep, a crazy Muggle woman who was desperate for a daughter stole her (and left Harry, because she didn’t want a boy). She renamed the baby (who’s original name I haven’t really decided on yet) Julia Whittaker.

Julia lives with her ‘mother’ until she gets her Hogwarts letter. There’s obviously going to be some sort of conflict between them here, but Julia goes anyway.

Harry and Julia are none the wiser to the fact that they were related. In fact, Harry finds out when he sees his whole family in the Mirror of Erised. And… that’s all I’ve got. 🙂

Update:

For the person asking, my penname is RoseMary, but there’s not much point going on it. I haven’t even got anything on it yet =)

✅ Answers

? Favorite Answer

  • I love HP fanfics, but I’ve read a lot of Harry sibling stories, including ones where one sibling is stolen away.

    I think the biggest problem you’ll have, is getting people to like Julia. It sounds like she’ll be a big part of the story, more so than Harry, so you have to handle her carefully. Make sure she’s not perfect, the readers will maul her if she seems slightly Mary Sue-ish.

    See also  The hunger game triliogy a huge dissapointment?

    I do like the Mirror of Erised idea, it’s very interesting, but what are you going to do about the Dursleys? They would have been told Harry had a sister, Lily may have had trouble with her sister, but she still would have told her, why wouldPetuniah keep that from Harry?

    The story could still happen, and it does sound interesting, ^_^ Just have long chapters (, to , words) good grammar/not OOC characters, and you’ll get some reconition.

    Good luck!

    Source(s): I’m Scorpia on ff.net, 🙂

  • Sounds excellent! What’s your penname? I wanna read it!

  • Really fantastic!!!!

    Why don’t you try to write stories of your own? I’m sure you can…. you are really talented as a writer!!!!

  • Other Related Questions

    WhAt ShOuLd I nAmE mY cHaRaCtErS?

    Answers Favorite AnswerNaming a character should feel like a parent naming their children. You wouldn't give that task to anyone else (least of all strangers). I'm guessing you don't feel that strongly about your story.. Jane Jennings. Mr. Wang. Bill Harting. Landon . Rachel . Charlie Lincoln. Ethan. Jane Jones, Jissle, Jankles, Jeels, Joles, Jamago,James. (I made all of these, other than Jones & James, up xD). Mr. Barker, Mr. James, Mr. Hudson, Mr. Lang.. Reg, Benson, Jacob, Kane.. Daniel, Sam, Aaron, Cameron, Justin.. Belle, Wella, Susie, Anne.. Cameron, Justin, Ben, Nathan, John, Jonathan.. Harold, Ken, Quinn, Samuel, Dan, Brad. Hope I helped! I do know I re-used the names, sorry they just fit with the description. :)Source(s): My brain.

    Whether attitude depends life experience or your life experience constitutes your attitude ?
    See also  What are some good books about teen drama that are not just for girls?

    Answers Favorite AnswerGood question. Attitude is the base. Attitude helps in engaging in action, which builds experience, experience in turn enriches the basic attitude and people become more experience and so on.Life experiences form the person you are today of which your attitude is a reflection. Life experience is good and bad meaning your attitude can reflection of specific recent or recurring events. Both to your question because attitude depends on also how you deal with random events that occur.I think, Natural Attitude,Taking the Coaching with the Experiences, and Dancing Accordingly, with the Changing STEPS, with the Better Dance or with the Worst Dance Steps, Depending on the Personal Attitude of the Understanding of the DANCES.Attitude comes down to thinking and belief choices Balaji.Good Luck.Best Wishes.Mars Mission Soon In A Galaxy Near Yours..Source(s):Studies..Sure it can. I could handiest feel down for a whilst, but after the clouds are cleared, i'll proceed my existence as natural. I no longer dwell in the past dangerous expertise, as an alternative be taught from it. The sector is giant, so why stay at that one factor and not moving on. I is also equipped to experience something quality.It is like asking "what was first, Read more

    Which is the more important legacy for Classical Athens, the democracy or philosophy?

    Which is the more important legacy for Classical Athens, the democracy or philosophy? Why? Which legacy had the greatest influence on western culture?Democracy by far. Nowadays everybody favors democracy it seems (save a tiny but growing minority of enlightened people) but few even heard of Plato, Aristotle etc.Its democracy made an impact on the Western Culture. Its values and philosophy of Plato and Aristotle had influenced the world and particularly the theory of democracy.Favorite AnswerDemocracy by far. Nowadays everybody favors democracy it seems (save a tiny but growing minority of enlightened people) but few even heard of Plato, Aristotle etc.Its democracy made an impact on the Western Culture. Its values and philosophy of Plato and Aristotle had influenced the world and particularly the theory of democracy.

    See also  Any readers for a novel I'm in the middle of writing?
    Would you please give me your opinion of which words should end this chapter?

    conversation-type novel: This may seem weird, not knowing what was previously written.Dear Wayne, Interesting launch for a Vietnam story. No ambushed patrol or shoot 'em up. Just that odd sign, the Kraits, and the black pajama boys to get out attention, then I was there; this is my story. You have my vote. I'll read on. Signed, Jerry PetersonDear Wayne, Okay the snakes and the prophetic sign gave me a serious case of the heebie-jeebies. You get my vote for most powerful images. - signed, Jennifer HDear Jennifer, Highway traffic gives me the heebie-jeebies. Do you catch my drift? Snakes, leeches, scorpions, and enemies that rustle the leaves- they all have a degree of logic, or a conscience of sorts, and they, whether they intend to or not, they give us early warning signs. -But those of you who drive on the highways are the bravest people on Earth. Why? You face dangers on a daily bases, more than just days of your life - which was my tour in Vietnam. And you face those highway dangers, knowing full well, there are no early warning signs. When a tire blows-out on the highway or a truck driver goes to sleep Read more

    Leave a Comment